As a capstone to the MA in Climate Action Leadership (MACAL) program, our cohort prepared and presented poster projects, which showcased our learning within and alongside the program. Some posters were focused on outcomes of course-based learning, some were focused on projects from the professional sphere (and how student learning in the program supported abilities to take on this work), and some were focused on thesis summaries. The breadth of topics covered was a testament to the varied and dynamic interests of our cohort, and how the MACAL program was able to support learning across these diverse interests.
In creating my own poster I developed skills in poster presentation and took a close look at academic research focused on Indigenous-led conservation in Canada. In terms of skills in poster presentation, I learned to find a balance between presenting the information in a simple and visually appealing format and including enough information to make the poster relevant. This was an iterative process that took a considerable amount of time to complete. I also learned to navigate the basic functions of a piece of design software, which is something I have very little prior experience with. In terms of the topic itself, I found that I needed to gain a strong understanding of the research landscape to be able to choose the elements that made the most sense to highlight in the poster. While the word count on the poster itself is small, it was necessary to have a comprehensive understanding of the topic to be able to synthesize and summarize key findings. I focused on Indigenous-led conservation in Canada but also reviewed literature from around the world to provide context and to allow me to compare and contrast practices.
My poster project was based on learnings from an elective course entitled Global Perspectives on Indigenous Ways of Knowing. However, I was also able to bring in learnings and readings from other courses, making the poster an artifact of my two-plus year journey through the MACAL program. I chose the topic of Indigenous-led conservation as it is a priority and focus for the conservation organization that I work for, which created a tie between my professional and academic life.
I was interested to review and engage with the posters created by the students in my cohort. A number of students focused on projects from or elements of their professional lives. I was impressed to see how these students were able to integrate their learning from the MACAL program into their work, and then in turn showcase their work in academic format. This bridge between the academic and the professional is a testament to practitioner-focus of the program (for those that chose this stream).
Other students used their posters to present their thesis projects. It was interesting to get insights into the research that the students chose to undertake. It also helped me to gain an appreciation of the deeply involved work associated in a thesis project.
Overall, the experience of creating a poster helped me to develop a skill that I had not yet had the opportunity to develop in this program or in past education programs. The experience of reviewing and engaging with the posters of the students in my cohort gave me a sense of appreciation about how program learnings were being applied in a broad suite of ways, in both academic and professional spheres.
The Climate Action Accelerator was the final engagement that our class participated in together prior to program completion – some attended in person and some attended virtually. The poster presentations were the first part of this engagement, followed by two days of facilitated workshops.
My biggest take-away from the workshops was that my cohort had – over the course of the MACAL program – developed the language and the context to be able to articulate complex analyses of climate leadership values. My cohort shared reflections about their own leadership capacity, strengths, and areas of improvement as well as reflections on the state of climate leadership more broadly. From our time in the program, we shared common understandings of topics like complex systems, climate communication, and leadership that allowed us to have meaningful and nuanced dialogue, within the cohort and with other participants. I look forward to continuing this dialogue within the community of practice that our cohort is engaged in.
The Climate Action Accelerator provided a way for our cohort to share our learning and reflections from the last two-plus years in the MACAL program and to think forward about our role as climate action leaders. The days were full and long, but the level of engagement and the sense of commitment to climate action was deeply felt.
The work that I am embarking on in climate action can be brought into focus by the following concept map, which answers the questions of where, why, and what.
The work that I am intending to do in the climate action space is underpinned by my values. These values, or motivations, for working in climate action are three-fold and are explained by the following:
A commitment to my children. My children are too young to understand climate change in any fulsome sense at the moment. When they come to realize the full impacts of climate change, I’d like to be able to tell them that I worked hard on contributing to solutions and will continue to do so as long as I can. I also want to model a commitment to finding solutions to climate change that my children can follow, in their own way and under their own terms.
A desire to work on interesting problems with interesting people. Climate change is an endlessly complex and interesting problem. A career working on climate change will necessarily be dynamic and evolving. The field also attracts an array of interesting and dedicated people with whom I am excited to collaborate with. When there are wins in the climate space, I want to share in celebrating the wins with others; when there are losses, I want to help shoulder those losses.
A desire to work on one of the most pressing issues of our time. I hesitate to frame climate change as the most pressing issue of our time, because I think that the degree to which an issue is pressing depends on who we are and where we are positioned in society. However, there is no arguing that climate change is an incredibly pressing issue. The problem demands our attention and it feels important for me to heed those demands.
I intend to work on climate change at a local or regional scale. I have lived in the Kootenay region since I was ten years old and feel an intimate connection with the area and a desire to see the region thrive in spite of a changing climate. I enjoy seeing the outputs of my work in action and I enjoy collaborating and building networks with others in my local context. Having said that, I think it is important to share work across wider geographic networks, as many solutions can be implemented in different regions with only minor changes intended to serve local realities.
I intend to work on climate change from an organizational support role. I have experience in finance and competency in operations that will help me to support organizations that work on climate change. I am a systems thinker that can help organizations optimize their impact by developing and streamlining processes and procedures. While my work may not be project-based, my knowledge of climate change and climate solutions (developed through my education, work history, and personal learning) will help me to understand the organizations I work for, tailor my work to that context, and be part of leadership discussions and decisions.
In my current workplace, we are undergoing a change that will see more structure implemented. The organization is growing very rapidly, and the number of employees is necessitating the change. With over thirty employees (and soon, even more), the leadership team is striving to create a structure that addresses the unique characteristics of our organization. The organization works across BC (and increasingly in Alberta and the Yukon) and works across a number of different climate change initiatives (for example, our work covers topics such as building retrofits, electric and active mobility, and greenhouse gas emissions inventories). The leadership team is working to create a structure that ensures that each team can develop expertise in a certain topic area, while cross-fertilization can happen across teams to combat the effect of siloes. While topic areas are the defining factor in determining team composition, there is also consideration given to organizing employees based on regional affiliations, so that employees can develop networks and capacity in certain geographic areas. Lastly, the leadership team is considering opportunities for effective mentorship within the organization.
Change leadership can operate in a number of ways, including directed change, planned change, and iterative change (Kerber & Buono, 2018). To date, the process described above has occurred as directed and planned change. To begin with, the leadership team noted that structural change was going to be implemented and detailed which people on the executive team would lead the change. This is an example of directed change, where the “the role of the change leader is to decide and announce the change” (Kerber & Buono, 2018, p. 57). However, as the change process moved forward, there was opportunity for all employees to provide feedback on draft plans and engage with the leadership team on the topic of the change initiative. This is an example of planned change, where the process involves flexibility and wide participation (Kerber & Buono, 2018, p. 57).
It makes sense that the process began as a directed change, as it simply may not have been initiated without clear direction from the executive team. However, once initiated, the process may have been best suited to iterative change. Kerber and Buono (2018) note that problems with high business complexity and high socio-technical uncertainty are appropriate to be dealt with through iterative change (p. 58), where the process is based on a direction rather than a specific goal (p. 57). In the case of my organization, there is an element of high business complexity; although the organization is not large or transnational, it does deal with many topic areas across a number of provinces and territories that have their own unique characteristics. The socio-technical uncertainty is reasonably high as well, as creating a new organizational structure is a problem that could have a number of different outcomes and the exact solution is unknown at the outset.
It will be interesting to watch this change initiative through to its conclusion and identify how the process unfolds with the lens of different types of change leadership.
Over the past couple of weeks our Leading Change in Organizations and Communitiesclass has explored the concept of polarity management, a practice that focuses on two ideas in tension as polarities to be managed rather than a problem to be solved (Beach & Joyce, 2009, p. 64). Polarities, by their nature, are not solved; polarities are managed by giving each pole appropriate attention to try to optimize outcomes (Beach & Joyce, 2009, p. 67).
One polarity in my own life that is worthwhile exploring is the tension between accepting/ enjoying life as it stands and working on the difficult topic of climate change. For the first pole, I sometimes wonder whether I should maximize my enjoyment of life by pursuing recreational activities, family time, or relaxation, rather than concerning myself with climate change issues. This can certainly be an attractive proposition, especially when the work of climate action feels heavy. The other pole calls me to spend time and engage with the topic of climate change in whatever way I can. When taken to the extreme, the pole asks me why I would spend time on anything other than climate issues, given their pressing nature and level of impact.
Looking back, I have certainly thought of this tension as an ‘either/or’ proposition in the past, in which only one choice was correct (Beach & Joyce, p. 64). In fact, it makes much more sense to think of the two ways to live as polarities to be managed. For example, it is necessary for me to spend time relaxing with family or friends in order to feel refreshed after focusing on climate issues in my schooling or at work. If I don’t take the downtime, my ability to work through problems in the climate space is negatively affected; I become less productive, creative, and resilient. On the other hand, if I do not spend time pursuing action in the climate space, I feel ill at ease and lacking purpose. I feel a sense of malaise and am not able to fully enjoy any of my time, whether it is spent relaxing or otherwise.
If I think of how I spend my time as a polarity, I can become attuned to the issue and start to find ways to optimize the balance between the two poles. While I may lean too far to one side or the other at times, knowing that each side of the polarity serves a purpose can help me find my way back to the right space between the two. And who says you can’t read the IPCC reports at the beach, anyways?
Reference Beach, P. G., & Joyce, J. (2009). Escape from flatland: Using polarity management to coach organizational leaders from a higher perspective. International Journal of Coaching in Organizations, 7(2), 64-83.
I see myself as someone who is introverted, quiet, and uncomfortable in the spotlight. For a long time, I assumed that these characteristics did not lend themselves to leadership. I imagined leaders as the charismatic, popular students in high school who made enthusiastic bids at student council spots. Or my outgoing friends who love to talk in front of large groups – the more people the better.
But, as I reflect on the idea of leadership, and the more experience I have in different organizations and social groups, I realize that leadership is not only about standing up in front of a crowd. While an outgoing attitude can certainly help with some leadership styles, I now realize that there are many types of leadership, including those that are quiet and unassuming.
I think my leadership strengths are as follows:
I like to be well-prepared. I tend to speak up only when my ideas are well-thought out and backed my evidence or reason. While this means that I do not always participate in ideation or brainstorming sessions, I am happy to share my thoughts on the finer details of project creation or implementation.
I am good at bringing big ideas to a scale that is practical. I tend to focus on problems associated with a project. While this can feel overwhelming for me at times, it can also help highlight issues and ensure projects are well-planned.
I love logistics and organization. I like to ensure that plans run smoothly. I enjoy giving my attention to the moving parts of a project and making sure that everything is well-coordinated.
While I feel pride in being able to bring the above attributes to the table as a leader, I am also aware that there are elements of my leadership practice that could use strengthening. I would particularly like to focus on being more comfortable with conflict. Brown (2018) wrote about how practicing courage in the face of difficult conversations may cause discomfort (even physical discomfort), but that it is truly only momentary. I’d like to remember this and add that – while the discomfort may be fleeting – the pride felt in doing the right thing lasts much longer.
There are myriad types of conflict, but there are a few that I’d like to become better at dealing with. One, I’d like to tap into courage when I feel my values are being compromised. For example, I’d like to speak up when someone tells an off-colored joke or anecdote. Second, I’d like to be able to raise issues I am having at work or in other settings. I often find myself complaining about situations to friends or family rather than trying to deal with them in the arena in which they are occurring. I’d like to seek positive outcomes by sharing my point of view, as well as hearing the perspectives of others.
The CALS 504 course made me think about our Design Thinking Challenge prototype in the context of the business case. If we were to build out a business case for our prototype, what would the conclusions be? I think one of the weaker aspects of our prototype is that we did not consider how it would be funded. The financial inputs would be significant. However, through the different phases of prototype development, we spent our time exploring software development, the school system and its curriculum, and cultural sensitivity. We did not, unfortunately, have time to interview business experts or potential funders.
In the absence of figuring out the costing and funding of our prototype, I decided to explore how we might have gone about this, given more time and resources for prototype development. After all, a business case can be viewed as a “guiding light” (Siegelaub & Herman, 2009, section 4) as a project moves forward over time. A business case is an important aspect of project development. Without a business case, an organization may waste resources on a project that does not aid the organization in fulfilling its objectives (Siegelaub & Herman, 2009, section 3)
We would need funds for software development, curriculum development, outreach to the school system, legal expertise, and administration and overhead. We would need to figure out an approximate dollar value for each of these budget items before bringing our prototype to potential funders. This would take a significant upfront effort, most likely inputs of time and energy which would not be compensated.
For a business case, we would also need to provide values for the potential benefits that our prototype would bring. This, I think, would prove more challenging than providing values for the costs of the prototype. In our CALS 504 course, we completed a business case analysis that looked at adaptation actions that could be implemented during heat waves to help the homeless population of Colwood, BC. In my project, I found that figuring out a dollar value for the benefits of the adaptation actions was much more difficult than assigning dollar values to the costs of the actions.
I think the most obvious funding mechanism would be through a foundation. We would need to find a foundation whose values aligned with that of our prototype, and who would be willing to invest a significant amount of money into its development. One consideration would be to find seed funding to develop a small pilot project, and then seek and secure further funding once the pilot has (hopefully) shown promise and success.
Another potential source of funding for development could be through a MITACS Accelerate internship. For this, we would need to find an organization willing to host an employee (who would be partially funded through MITACS) who would use their time to develop the prototype further, and ready it for market. Though there would likely need to be further funding to get the prototype fully to market, this pathway would provide a good start.
Lastly, we could consider crowdfunding as a way to fund the initial costs of development. Again, this could provide the money to test the prototype in a pilot phase before trying to secure further funding through a foundation.
A business case would help guide the vision of our prototype and would help us bring it to potential funders. It is an important component of bringing a project to fruition. We were not able to explore this aspect during the Design Thinking Challenge, but I am glad that I gained tools and insights into business case planning from the CALS 504 course that can be applied in my student and work life in the future.
References
Herman, B., & Siegelaub, J. M. (2009). Is this really worth the effort? The need for a business case. Project Management Institute. https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/need-business-case-6730
It is important for municipalities to be forward thinking in the face of the escalating climate crisis. Municipalities need to know what conditions they will be facing in the future and what they can do to prepare for these conditions. With this in mind, the Columbia Basin Rural Development Institute (CBRDI; 2020) prepared a report titled State of Climate Adaptation: Town of Golden. I live in the Town of Golden and was drawn to exploring this report to gain a better understanding of my community’s response to a changing climate.This blog post will seek to summarize and critically analyze the report.
The report was created as a tool to be used in local planning and decision-making efforts in Golden, BC. It zeroes in on climate projections for the community, current local impacts, and current and potential adaptation measures. The authors of the report used the State of Climate Adaptation and Resilience in the Basin (SoCARB) indicators as a basis for their analysis. The SoCARB program measures changes to climate as well as progress on climate adaptation and resilience at the community level using a set of indicators (Columbia Basin Trust, 2015). Within the report, five “thematic pathways” (CBRDI, 2020, p. 6) were explored: wildfire, water supply, agriculture, flooding, and extreme weather.
The authors used a number of approaches in writing the report. First, they used a top-down approach, which is characterized as being conducted by a small group of individuals internal to an organization and having limited engagement with outside stakeholders (CCME, 2021, p. 9). Further iterations could be strengthened by providing a means for public input. This would not necessarily indicate a wholesale change in method. The same top-down approach could still be used, but there could be a draft made available for public comment before completion. That way, the lived experiences of residents could either validate or perhaps question some of the analysis.
Secondly, the authors of the report used a mix of qualitative and quantitative data, but relied more heavily on a qualitative analysis. The climate projections used were quantitative in nature. The adaptation actions and impacts were described qualitatively; they were not assigned a number or ranking to highlight their importance relative to one and other. Because there was no ranking in terms of the relative importance for the impacts, especially, it is difficult to know what should be priority focus areas for the community in dealing with climate change. This is an aspect of the report that could be improved upon with future iterations.
Thirdly, the authors used a comprehensive approach in their analysis. While a tightly-scoped approach would see an evaluation of one sector or thematic pathway, a comprehensive approach sees an assessment done across a number of sectors or thematic pathways (CCME, 2021, p. 11). Because the report highlights and evaluates five thematic pathways, it falls firmly into the category of a comprehensive assessment. This makes sense in that the authors of the report were attempting to describe the state of climate adaptation (as well as climate projections and impacts) in Golden as a whole.
As noted at the start of this blog post, the report was written to aid in local decision-making and planning processes. I think the report has partially delivered on this objective. For example, the evaluation of adaptation actions shows both what is already in place and what can be implemented or strengthened in terms of adaptation. However, because there is no ranking of what impacts have the most vulnerability or risk associated with them, it would be hard for decision-makers to choose wisely in terms of further adaptation measures to focus on. As a next step, the Town of Golden could consider undertaking a full climate change risk assessment in order to prioritize areas for action in the face of changing climate conditions. Within that assessment, the Town could seek to include more voices from every demographic to ensure a holistic understanding of climate impacts in Golden.
As a resident of Golden, I am happy to know the Town has been thinking about climate change and its future impacts. I am hopeful, too, that the Town will consider conducting a full climate change risk assessment when resources allow.
When I think about glaciers receding up mountainsides, losing ground slowly and yet much too fast, I feel a visceral sense of panic (Sander-Green, 2021). I worry that the water supply will suddenly dry up in the small town where I live, our aquifer dwindling alongside the glaciers. I dwell on the fish in nearby streams, deprived of the cool flush of glacier water. I envision the view changing dramatically, new rocky outcrops exposed, as I leave my home and head east through the mountains of Glacier National Park. After all, glaciers are an intensely local phenomenon here in Golden, British Columbia – they sit atop the Purcell Mountains to the west and blanket much of the Rocky Mountains to the east. And, yes, they are melting (in fact, under a medium emissions pathway, the glaciers of Western Canada are predicted to lose 74% – 96% of their volume by the end of this century; Bush et al., 2019, p. 12).
In our Masters of Arts in Climate Action Leadership program (MACAL), we recently completed a course titled Communication for Climate Action (CALS 502). In CALS 502, we learned about tailoring climate communications to specific audiences or segments of the population (Hine et al., 2016). One way we can do this is to bring up specific, local examples of climate change (Maibach et al., 2011). To put this another way, we should talk about rising seas in coastal regions, droughts in agricultural areas, and – indeed – melting glaciers where they exist (Sander-Green, 2021). It may seem like an obvious idea, but sometimes seemingly obvious ideas can remain hidden until they are explicitly introduced. It is a learning that I will bring forward with me into coursework and beyond.
Specifically, this learning is helpful in informing my thinking about our team’s design challenge project. The design challenge project is a year-long project in which MACAL teams come up with a concept for a climate action project that is based on principles of open learning. Our team is working through a project that would see the creation of a piece of software that connects students on the topic of climate change. Using the software, students would be able to read about local impacts of climate change. They would also be prompted to undertake a climate action project of their own and then upload a summary of the project to share. Learning about the importance of local framing for climate change communication in CALS 502, I feel confidence in the direction of our team’s design challenge project.
Additionally, through readings in the MACAL program, I have deepened my appreciation for the role Indigenous knowledge has to play in addressing climate change. As an example, Menzies and Butler (2006) wrote about how the site-specific ecological knowledge that many Indigenous people hold can be a critical aspect in seeking long-term sustainability in an ecosystem (p. 1). Although the authors were writing about resource conservation, I believe the concept can be applied to climate change, as well. With this in mind, our team has decided to incorporate Indigenous knowledge directly into our prototype. Local examples of Indigenous knowledge and storytelling will be made available alongside climate science. Our hope is that this will give students access to information across disciplines and world views, providing them with more tools and ideas to help address climate change.
Hine, D. W., Phillips, W. J., Cooksey, R., Reser, J. P., Nunn, P., Marks, A. D., Loi, N., & Watt, S. E. (2016). Preaching to different choirs: How to motivate dismissive, uncommitted, and alarmed audiences to adapt to climate change?. Global Environmental Change, 36, 1-11. ttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2015.11.002
Menzies, C. & Butler, C. (2006). Introduction: Understanding ecological knowledge. In Butler, C. (Ed.), Traditional Ecological Knowledge and natural resource management (pp 1-17). University of Nebraska Press.
A few weeks ago, our Communication for Climate Action class completed a content creation assignment (note: it was not posted to this blog). For that assignment, I wrote a grant proposal for the curbside collection of organic waste and a composting facility in Golden, BC. I focused on the benefits of diverting organic waste from the landfill and on examples of operational compost collection programs. The intended audience was the committee reviewing grants and I assumed that they would have a level of proficiency with technical language with regards to landfills and greenhouse gas emissions.
For this assignment, I am remixing the content from the prior assignment to reach a different audience with different accessibility needs. I’ve created two new pieces of content to help reach a broad spectrum of people. The audience, in this case, is the general population of Golden, BC (my hometown). Note that the reference list for both pieces of content is found at the end of this post.
Part 1
For the first piece of content, I’ve created a hypothetical Twitter campaign to convince the residents of Golden, BC to vote yes in a municipal referendum on implementing curbside collection of organic waste. For this campaign, I worked with the assumption that residents have some knowledge of the referendum via other means (ie. conversations with other residents, outreach campaigns by the town, or newspaper articles). With this in mind, I was able to craft my tweets without providing extensive background information. My idea was that these tweets would be part of a larger community conversation, and that residents would be posting their own tweets and commenting on mine, as well. I tried to add prompts to some tweets to start community conversations. I did not assume any level of expertise with regards to landfills or greenhouse gas emissions. My goal was to make the campaign accessible to the general population by using simple language and avoiding technical jargon (like using the word pollution instead of emissions or rotting instead of decomposing). I also made the tweets short in order to reduce the cognitive load necessary to process the message. The techniques listed above are introduced in Rallo et al.’s (2019) work. Although the handbook is aimed towards those practicing graphic design, the portions of the handbook that deal with text provided helpful insights into accessibility for this assignment. As per Rallo et al. (2019), communicators should “aim for clarity and economy while avoiding needless complexity” (p. 13). This is what I aimed to accomplish (and it’s worth noting that Twitter’s character limit helps with this, as well). Dupar et al. (2019) also introduced the concept of using language appropriate to your audience in their work. Additionally, I made the case to Twitter users to share the content to (hopefully) reach a wider audience, further increasing the accessibility. Lastly, because Twitter is a computer-based platform, people with sight impairments would be able to use screen readers to have the tweets read out loud to them or translated to braille.
I put the relevant sources at the end of each Tweet to satisfy the citation requirements; however, my vision is that the citations would not appear in the Twitter campaign itself.
Twitter Campaign
30% of Golden’s landfill waste is made up of organics. We can do better with curbside organics pickup. Use #LetsCompostGolden to spread the word. (Source: Maura Walker & Associates, 2015)
Did you know that when organic matter rots in the landfill it produces methane, a potent greenhouse gas? Composting can reduce methane pollution. Composting = #ClimateAction. #LetsCompostGolden #VoteYesToCompost. (Source: City of Kamloops. n.d.)
Apple cores don’t belong in the landfill. Cast your ballot for curbside organic collection in #GoldenBC. You’ll be voting for: ↓ Reduced landfill capacity needs, ↑ More compost for farmers and gardeners, ↓ Reduced greenhouse gas pollution. (Sources: Bong et. al, 2017; Government of BC, n.d.)
Did you know that Vancouver, Squamish, and Gibsons all have curbside collection of organic waste? Let’s join them, #GoldenBC! #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden #ClimateAction (Sources: City of Kamloops, n.d.; Town of Gibsons, n.d.)
What do banana peels have to do with the #ClimateCrisis? A lot! Composting organics instead of sending them to the landfill is a powerful way to reduce methane pollution. #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden #ClimateAction (Source: City of Kamloops, n.d.)
Chicken bones, hardened bits of cheese, avocado pits, paper towel. These things end up in our landfill everyday, but it doesn’t have to be that way.. Cast your ballot for curbside organics collection so that EVERYONE can compost. #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden
Attention apartment dwellers! Backyard compost may not be an option for you, but curbside organics collection is. #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden
#LetsCompostGolden: Talk about curbside organic collection with your neighbours to get more people to #VoteYesToCompost
In Canada, methane pollution from organic waste rotting in landfills is a big problem. #GoldenBC may be a small town, but we can be part of the solution. Curbside organic collection would reduce pollution and help combat the #ClimateCrisis. (Source: Government of Canada, 2017)
Gardeners call compost ‘black gold’. What if we made our own black gold in #GoldenBC from household organic waste? Comment below ⇩ if you’d use it in your garden. #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden
What can you do to help avert the climate crisis today? #VoteYesToCompost and tell a friend to, too.
#ClimateAction can be wind farms, solar power, or biking to work. Did you know composting can also contribute to #ClimateAction? #VoteYesToCompost #LetsCompostGolden
⇧ composting = ⇩ methane = ⇩ climate crisis. #VoteYesToCompost (Source: City of Kamloops. n.d.)
Part 2
For the second portion of this assignment, I have created a Google Slides document to be presented at a Town Hall-type event. This event would be part of the same campaign as above. The aim is to have residents vote yes in a municipal referendum on implementing curbside collection of organic waste. As with the Twitter campaign, the intended audience is the general population of Golden, BC. Accessibility is addressed by providing a visual presentation (Google Slides) as well as an audio presentation. Therefore, the needs of people with both hearing and sight impairments are addressed. Of course, accessibility for those with mobility challenges would need to be addressed in choosing the venue, as well. To further contribute to accessibility, I have chosen to use a large, easily readable font. Specifically, I used the Arial font, as this is rated as one of the preferred fonts by those with vision and/ or reading difficulties (Rallo et al., 2019). I chose to limit my use of text in the Google Slides presentation to reduce cognitive load, which is also in line with Rallo et al.’s (2019) design principles. In contrast to my tweets, I used some more technical language in my presentation, but I have explained any potentially confusing terms or phrases (see the speaker notes). I have tried to use more complex language only when absolutely necessary. This is based on the work of Rallo et. al. (2019) and Dupar et al. (2019). I have added photos to the presentation to increase audience engagement, based on the work of Dupar et al. (2019) and Hodson (2019). Lastly, I’ve added Alt Text to these photos, in case people with vision impairments want to access the presentation from their home computers at a later date.
Note that there are also speaker notes that go along with the presentation. Also note that citations are found in the speaker notes as well as this text. The reference list for both follows.
References – for Twitter campaign and Google Slides presentation
Bong, C. P. C., Lim, L. Y., Ho, W. S., Lim, J. S., Klemeš, J. J., Towprayoon, S., Ho, C.S., & Lee, C. T. (2017). A review on the global warming potential of cleaner composting and mitigation strategies. Journal of Cleaner Production, 146, 149-157. doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.07.066
Hodson, J. (2019). An ecological model of climate marketing: A conceptual framework for understanding climate science related attitude and behavior change. Cogent Social Sciences, 5(1), 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2019.1625101
Rallo, A., Forest, E., Kuo, J., Boutilier, R., & Li, E. (2019). Access Ability 2: A practical handbook on accessible graphic design. Revised + Supersized Second Edition. The Association of Registered Graphic Designers.
Once upon a time, a birch tree stood sentry in front of my home. It started small, as all trees do, but by the year 2021 it stood at least ten meters tall. It had papery bark that peeled easily and knots in its trunk that told stories of its past.
Everyday, the birch provided gifts to us, the residents of the house that sat behind it. In the spring, it hosted chattering birds who added music to our days and gave us a reason to stare idly out the window. In the summer, it cast shade on our home, providing valuable cooling. In the fall, it dropped its leaves onto the ground below. We raked the leaves and added them to our garden as mulch. In the winter, it provided a cozy location for tea with a friend. Chairs were set out in the snow under its bare canopy, next to its thick trunk – the perfect location for a good conversation.
Until one day, climate change started to disrupt the way that the birch gave to us throughout the seasons. Over the next twenty five years, everything changed for this tree.
Because of climate change, far fewer birds visited us in the spring. For some, their migration patterns were disrupted. Sadly, some bird species didn’t survive at all. Their young hatched too early in the spring, when plentiful food wasn’t yet available.
Because of climate change, the tree stopped providing enough cooling for our home in the summer. We became uncomfortable in the intensifying heat and had to find other means of cooling our home.
Because of climate change, the tree grew less leaves, as it was stressed by changing conditions. We lost some of the precious mulch that we used to spread over the garden in the fall, which helped our vegetables grow robust the following summer.
Because of climate change, we set chairs out for wintertime tea in sloppy mud, rather than crunchy snow. The tree dripped water on us, melting when – in the past – it would have stood frozen for months on end.
Until finally, the tree could no longer survive.It was not able to satisfy its thirst for water. It did not have the stability it needed – season after season – to know when its leaves should bud, grow, and drop. It did not know when to store energy and when to spend it on new growth. It missed the snowy winter and the chattering birds. It slowly began to die off from the inside, and then suddenly limbs ten meters off the ground were succumbing to stress and falling dramatically to the ground.
And everyday after that, for a long time, the climate continued to change. Where the tree used to stand, new life began to grow. Grasses and shrubs overtook the area. Changing landscapes were something that we, as humans, had to get used to. Trees died off and new species – sometimes other trees, or grasses, or bushes – took their place.
*** This post was structured based on the idea of the story spine, which helps stories take shape with a set of prompts. The prompts I used were based on those in Cunningham’s (2017) work. The story spine idea was originally developed by Kenn Adams in How to Improvise a Full-Length Play: The Art of Spontaneous Theater and popularized by Emma Coats, who worked for Pixar, in a series of tweets (Cunningham, 2017).
Beyond its use in helping a storyteller develop the structure of their story, Rotman (2017) showed that the story spine can be used in a workshop setting with people from different disciplines to “foster empathy, engagement, creativity, and reflection” (p. 304). Rotman also noted that, in these settings, storytelling using the story spine can act as a “social lubricant” (p. 308). Thinking in this context, the above post could be used in a workshop setting – for example, with different stakeholders in my community – to convey my feelings and thoughts about climate change in the local context. I wonder what other personal climate stories I could tell by using the story spine?
Rotman, S. (2017). “Once upon a time…” Eliciting energy and behaviour change stories using a fairy tale story spine. Energy Research & Social Science, 31, 303-310. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2017.06.033